Dr. Katherine M. Cole and the Miami Black-Market Babies
Matthew Egan's Story: Born in Miami in 1946, Still Searching for Answers
By Diana Kayla Hochberg
It started with a comment on social media.
I had shared a post about black-market babies when a woman named M. Woodward responded. We began talking, and what started as a wonderful conversation eventually turned into a friendship.
During one of our conversations, she told me about her former husband, Matthew LeRoy Egan Jr., who was born in Miami, Florida, in 1946.
Matthew was a black-market baby, she explained, and his early history was connected to Dr. Katherine M. Cole, a Miami practitioner whose involvement in questionable baby placements eventually became the subject of a federal investigation.
The more Woodward told me, the more I wanted to know.
Since then, I have connected with Matthew himself. We have spoken several times, and I am now helping him research his family tree, hoping to uncover information about the biological family he has never known.
What stays with me most is hearing Matthew's voice.
After all these years, I can still hear how much he wants answers. There are questions about his beginnings that have followed him throughout his life, and even now, he is still looking for closure.
I understand that feeling more than he probably realizes.
Here is part of his story.
Who Was Dr. Katherine M. Cole?
During the 1940s and 1950s, Miami was one of the places where babies were being placed with families through arrangements that sometimes bypassed the legal adoption system.
Dr. Katherine M. Cole, a naturopathic practitioner, operated a clinic on SW Eighth Street, also known as Calle Ocho, in Miami.
According to historical reporting published in November 2010, Cole reportedly arranged the placement of more than 1,000 babies between the 1930s and 1960s, many without legal adoption records.
Women facing unplanned pregnancies were reportedly housed in apartments and homes near her clinic. Cole delivered babies and arranged placements with couples seeking children.
Money changed hands, sometimes amounting to thousands of dollars.
In some cases, the people who took the babies home were listed on their birth certificates as their biological parents.
For those children, the birth certificate they grew up with could tell a completely different story from what actually happened.
In November 1955, a United States Senate subcommittee investigating interstate adoption practices held hearings in Miami. Dr. Cole testified during those hearings.
The proceedings included evidence involving falsified birth certificates bearing her signature.
One detail from her testimony caught my attention.
While describing a delivery at her office, Cole stated:
"My place is 4765—it was 4725 at that time."
Her testimony, recorded on page 220, provides two street numbers associated with her practice. Historical reporting identifies the earlier location as 4725 SW Eighth Street.
Whether the change reflected a move or a renumbering of the property remains unclear.
The investigation became part of the historical record. But for many of the children involved, the questions about their beginnings remained unanswered.
Today, some of those children are known as the Cole Babies.
Many have spent years trying to piece together their histories without the records most people take for granted.
Matthew Egan's Story: The Nurse and the Guest House
One of the most important parts of Matthew's story concerns Gertrude Egan, the woman who raised him.
Both Matthew and M. Woodward have told me that Gertrude worked as a nurse for Dr. Katherine Cole.
Gertrude was married to Matthew LeRoy Egan Sr.
According to Woodward, the couple lived on Flagler Street in Miami, where their property included a guest house.
That guest house was reportedly used to care for women recovering after giving birth.
Gertrude herself had undergone a hysterectomy at a young age and was unable to have children.
But there was something else Woodward told me that made me want to investigate this story further.
According to her account, Gertrude received a baby from Dr. Cole in exchange for the care she provided to the women.
That baby was Matthew.
Woodward also remembers seeing Matthew's birth certificate when she was young. Gertrude was listed as his biological mother, even though she could not have given birth to him.
She also recalled a woman known as Bee Bee who helped care for Matthew while Gertrude worked.
These details come from conversations with Matthew and Woodward. I have not yet found original documents independently confirming the reported arrangement, but their accounts have given me several leads to follow.
I keep wondering about that house on Flagler Street.
Who were the women who stayed there? Was the guest house connected to Cole's operation? Could Matthew's biological mother have been one of the women who received care there?
And does someone who knew Gertrude still remember something that could help Matthew?
Those are questions I hope we can begin to answer.
When M. Woodward Met Dr. Cole
One part of Woodward's story especially surprised me.
She actually met Dr. Cole.
When Woodward was expecting her first child, Matthew suggested that Dr. Cole deliver their baby.
Cole had been a longtime family friend, and Matthew knew her as the doctor who had delivered so many babies.
Woodward remembers visiting her in Miami.
By then, Cole was elderly and told the couple that she was no longer delivering babies.
Woodward also recalled hearing that Dr. Cole signed birth certificates in red ink.
That detail caught my attention because I had come across something similar while researching Cole's history.
In a 2010 newspaper investigation, retired Florida adoption official Josette Marquess reported that approximately 98 percent of the Cole birth certificates she had encountered were handwritten in bright red ink.
When I read that, I immediately thought about what Woodward had told me.
Of course, the color of ink alone cannot establish what happened when Matthew was born. But when you're searching for a history that may never have been properly documented, even a small detail can be worth examining.
Other Cole Babies Have Been Searching, Too
Matthew is not alone.
In October 2011, The Bulletin published the story of Cyn Bird, a New Jersey woman who discovered at age 46 that her parents had paid $2,500 for her as an infant through Dr. Cole's operation.
Her parents had reportedly traveled from Queens, New York, to Coral Gables, Florida, to receive her.
For years, Cyn had believed the people who raised her were her biological parents.
The truth emerged through a confession by her mother near the end of her life.
Like many other Cole babies, Cyn faced the challenge of searching without an accurate original birth record.
One detail from her story interested me.
She said a birth announcement had appeared in a Florida newspaper naming the father who raised her as her natural father.
That immediately made me think about Matthew.
He recently told me that he had been entered in a baby contest in Miami when he was young.
I've been looking through newspaper records from the late 1940s, hoping to find a photograph or announcement with his name.
I wonder whether somewhere in an old newspaper there might be a picture of Matthew as a baby, or perhaps a birth announcement that could tell us something more.
We haven't found one yet, but I'm continuing to look.
Searching for Gertrude's House
Another part of my research involves locating Gertrude Egan's home.
According to Woodward, the property was on Flagler Street and included the guest house where women reportedly recovered after giving birth.
So far, I haven't been able to establish its exact address.
However, a World War II draft registration card for Matthew LeRoy Egan Sr. gives his address as 151 NW 42nd Street in Miami.
That gives us another place to investigate, although it doesn't establish where Gertrude was living in 1946 or identify the guest house Woodward described.
I've been searching city directories, historical property records, and newspaper archives, hoping to find more.
I keep coming back to the possibility that someone may have an old photograph of that house, or remember the family who lived there.
Perhaps a neighbor knew Gertrude. Maybe someone remembers the women who stayed at the property.
After all these years, it's impossible to know what might still be out there.
But I want to keep looking.
The Search Continues
I've been working on Matthew's family tree, looking for anything that might lead us closer to his biological roots.
Names. Records. Family connections. Old photographs. Anything that might help.
I've learned from my own experience that searching for the truth is rarely straightforward.
Sometimes you find an answer. Other times, you find another question.
And sometimes you spend years looking for something that someone else may have known all along.
Matthew has lived an entire lifetime without knowing the full story of where he came from.
He has a family and a history of his own, but there is still a part of his beginning that remains unknown.
For people whose birth records were falsified, that missing information can go beyond knowing who their biological parents were. It can also mean not knowing their family's medical history or whether they have relatives they have never met.
I don't know what we will eventually find.
Some records may no longer exist, and many of the people who knew what happened are no longer here to tell us.
But as long as there are leads to follow, I want to help Matthew continue his search.
Having spent more than three decades searching for the truth about my own beginnings, I understand why finding answers matters so much to Matthew. I'm grateful M. Woodward reached out to me and introduced me to his story.
Were You One of Dr. Cole's Black-Market Babies?
I'm sharing Matthew Egan's story because someone reading this may recognize a name, a place, or a detail.
Were you born in Miami during the 1940s, 1950s, or 1960s?
Have you discovered that your birth certificate may not tell the truth about your biological parents?
Does the name Dr. Katherine M. Cole mean anything to you or your family?
Perhaps you remember Gertrude Egan, her husband Matthew LeRoy Egan Sr., or a house with a guest house on Flagler Street where women received care after giving birth.
Maybe you remember a woman known as Bee Bee, or a baby contest held in Miami during the late 1940s.
Perhaps you have an old photograph, a birth announcement, a letter, or a family story that never quite made sense.
If any of this sounds familiar, I would love to hear from you.
Were you, or someone in your family, part of the Miami black-market baby placements associated with Dr. Katherine M. Cole?
If you have information, an old photograph, a document, or even a family story that might help Matthew, please use the button below to contact me.
You never know which small detail might help someone find an answer they've been searching for.
Matthew is still looking for the truth about his beginnings, and I intend to keep helping him for as long as I can.
Everyone deserves the chance to know where they came from.
And perhaps someone reading this knows something Matthew has been waiting his whole life to learn.
Historical Sources and Research Notes
United States Senate, 1955–1956: Juvenile Delinquency: Interstate Adoption Practices—Miami, Florida. Hearings held November 14–15, 1955, published in 1956. Includes Dr. Katherine Cole's testimony and evidence concerning falsified birth certificates. Her statement identifying the street numbers 4725 and 4765 appears on page 220.
Read the official Senate hearing record
The Palm Beach Post, November 7, 2010: Audra D. S. Burch, The Cole Babies: Years Later, They Search for Identity. Includes a historical photograph of Dr. Cole during the November 15, 1955 hearings.
Read the article and view the historical photograph
The Miami Herald, November 12, 2010: Audra D. S. Burch, historical reporting about Dr. Cole, falsified birth certificates, and adults searching for their biological families.
Read the archived investigation
The Bulletin, October 21, 2011: Woman Sold at Birth, Now on a Quest for Answers. The story of Cyn Bird and her discovery that she was a Cole baby.
Family-history research: World War II draft registration card for Matthew LeRoy Egan Sr., identifying 151 NW 42nd Street as his residence at the time of registration.
Personal accounts: Conversations with Matthew LeRoy Egan Jr. and M. Woodward, 2026.
Author's note: The historical investigation into Dr. Cole is documented in the sources above. Details concerning Gertrude Egan's employment, the guest house, Matthew's reported placement, and his childhood are based on personal accounts shared with me by Matthew and M. Woodward. These specific circumstances remain part of an ongoing family-history investigation.
Diana Kayla Hochberg
Author of Connected: Finding My Truth